For a number of years, the topic of granting charitable status to private (or independent) schools in the United Kingdom has sparked intense debate and a great deal of discussion.
Put simply, the debate is centred on whether private institutions truly provide a public benefit worthy of tax exemptions. Charitable status is typically bestowed upon organisations in the UK that demonstrate a commitment to promoting public benefit and such organisations typically receive certain tax benefits as a result.
According to a recent report published via the House of Commons Library, ‘around half of independent schools in England were registered as charities’. While not all independent schools in the UK are affiliated with the Independent Schools Council (ISC), a 2023 Annual School Census found that 70% of their member schools across the UK had charitable status.
As many members of the public commonly associate private education with privilege and exclusivity, it is no surprise that the topic of charitable status for independent schools has proven to be such a contentious issue.
Exploring Charitable Status in Detail and Why People Are Talking About It Now
Although the topic is well documented, many people have not followed it in its entirety but the private school charitable status debate encompasses arguments from both sides, raising questions of equity, social mobility and the role of education in fostering a fairer society.
To grasp the essence of the debate, it is crucial to comprehend what charitable status actually entails and delve into the various perspectives, examining the arguments put forth by advocates and critics and (of course) exploring how private tutors play a role within all of this.
Charitable status has historically been associated with institutions like universities, hospitals, and organisations dedicated to advancing societal well-being but some argue that private schools should also be considered charities because they offer education and scholarships, which is believed to benefit society.
Notable figures in education such as Sir Michael Wilshaw, former Chief Inspector of Schools in England and Head of Ofsted and Geoff Barton, former General Secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders have expressed their perspectives, emphasising the need for accountability, transparency, and collaboration between private and state-funded school but the debate has been ongoing for several decades.
In contrast, events such as the “Give It Back” campaign by the Independent Schools Council in 2003 and (more recently) increasing concerns about social inequality, educational access and discussions surrounding tax policies have brought the conversation and debate around charitable status to the forefront once again.
What are the arguments in favour of private schools receiving charitable status?
Advocates of private school charitable status put forth compelling arguments in defence of independent schools retaining their tax-exempt status.
Contribution to Society and Increasing Educational Opportunities
Those in favour of granting charitable status to private schools highlight several key arguments. First and foremost, they argue that these schools offer high-quality education and contribute positively to society, with many private schools providing scholarships or bursaries to students from disadvantaged backgrounds thereby increasing access to educational opportunities.
Reduced Pressure on State Schools
Furthermore, advocates for charitable status assert that private schools relieve pressure on the state-funded education system, as families who can afford private education choose not to utilise public resources.
The Impact on Social Mobility
One of the key focal points of the debate is the impact of private school charitable status on social mobility. Supporters argue that private schools actively promote social mobility by offering scholarships and bursaries, allowing talented individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds to access quality education.
What about the criticisms of private schools receiving charitable status?
On the other side of the debate, critics raise valid concerns about the charitable status of private schools.
Concerns over Fairness and Equity
Those against private schools being granted charitable status raise valid concerns about fairness and equity within the current system. They argue that private schools operate as profit-oriented businesses while enjoying tax benefits which may not align with the spirit of charitable status.
This in turn raises questions about fairness and equity as public resources are not being allocated optimally but those arguing against charitable status believe public resources should be used to improve the state-funded education system instead.
The Impact on Social Mobility
While some supporters argue that private schools actively promote social mobility, critics contend that this approach merely addresses symptoms rather than tackling the underlying issues. As an example, critics suggest that addressing disparities within the state-funded education system should be prioritised to achieve genuine social mobility.
Critics also argue that the social exclusivity associated with private schools perpetuates social inequality and exacerbates existing divisions within society. They argue that these institutions cater to a privileged few and fail to address the root causes of educational disparities in the state-funded education system which should be the priority for promoting true social mobility.
Calls for Reform
Given the ongoing debates and concerns surrounding private school charitable status, there have been increasing calls for reform.
Some members of the public, experts and notable figures in education propose stricter criteria for charitable status, emphasising the need for private schools to demonstrate a more substantial contribution to the public benefit. Others advocate for a reassessment of the entire concept of charitable status for private schools, urging a comprehensive evaluation of their role within the broader framework of public education.
What Does the Debate Mean for Tutors?
As private tuition is often associated with wealth, it is thought that tutors may play a role in exacerbating educational inequality and further contributing to the strain on the state education system.
The notion that private tuition is something exclusively for affluent families is a common misconception as tuition comes in many forms with varying fees associated. While concerns around the impact of tuition within the charitable status debate are valid, it is important to note there are of course enormous benefits to private tuition.
At Hampstead and Frognal Tutors we know that for tuition to be successful, every student will need a tailored programme that caters to their individual needs, strengths, weaknesses and educational ambitions. There is simply not a one size fits all approach to tuition and, as an extension of that, there is not a one cost fits all model for tuition. It can be accessible to students from varying socio-economic backgrounds and can provide opportunities to “level the playing field” rather than create a greater divide.
To give an example, a student looking for some online support with essay writing to help elevate their exam responses may need fewer or less frequent sessions than a student with dyslexia who really struggles to write compelling answers in timed conditions and requires intensive support to get through upcoming exams.
Of course, one might argue that if the latter student is from a disadvantaged background they may then lack the funds or access to tuition to get the intensive support they need to excel but it is always worth getting in touch with an agency (or with the tutor directly) to discuss options.
At Hampstead and Frognal Tutors, our tutors are passionately dedicated to supporting children’s learning and we are not only committed to building bespoke programmes that help students develop but also finding practical solutions that work for families’ varying lifestyles and budgets.
As an alternative to private tuition, some schools in England offer free one-to-one or small group tuition to eligible students both at primary and secondary school level through the National Tutoring Programme.
Regardless of whether you engage a private tutor or a state allocated tutor, it is essential to find the right tutor. If a tutor’s content is not engaging and they are not able to tailor their programming to adapt to your child’s needs then the sessions become somewhat redundant and the opportunities to excel may be diminished.
We explore the areas to look out for in this post but a key consideration is to find someone who possesses not only the knowledge and skills to teach but also a personality and teaching style that resonates with your child.
The private school charitable status debate in the UK presents a complex and multifaceted issue. As discussions and deliberations continue around the schools and the role of tutors, striking a balance that ensures educational excellence, fairness and equal opportunities for all students, regardless of their background, remains essential to progress toward a more equitable and inclusive education system.
++
Useful Resources